Authentic Italian Subs and Specialty Sandwiches

Eating a sub or sandwich from Downtown Dempsey’s is a flavorful taste explosion for your mouth!

A lot of people ask us about our subs and sandwiches, and how they got their names. The sandwiches are named after people who are special to Tiffany.

We love to test flavor combinations, keeping in mind that people enjoy homemade traditional subs with quality ingredients that make your mouth want more! Each sandwich is hand-made, using only top-quality ingredients.

Below is a brief explanation and history of our sub sandwich creations.

We hope you are ready to bite into one of these delicious sandwiches! We have Specialty Subs and Authentic Italian Subs for you to choose from the next time you’re looking for a delicious lunch or dinner break!

Order ahead to pick up if you need lunch on the go, or sit back in our dining area and watch the downtown traffic while you relax and savor every bite!

Incredible Miss Izzy

Named after Loretta’s daughter, this authentic Italian Sub is made with Provolone Cheese and Ham, and topped with lettuce, tomatoes, vinegar, oil and Italian seasonings.

This is one of our customers’ favorite subs – we hope it becomes your favorite too!

The Jolly Jalapeno

You won’t even miss the meat! Enjoy this unique blend of flavors that combine for a one-of-a-kind vegetarian sandwich.

Savory seasoned mushrooms on top of a melted provolone and artichoke jalapeno spread. Toasted and topped with red onion, tomato, and lettuce.

Tanner’s Toasted Tuna Pita Pocket

If you prefer something other than sliced meat inside a sub bun, you might try Tanner’s Toasted Tuna Pita Pocket

We blend together Tuna, Mayo, Onions, & Celery and spoon it into a Pita Pocket, perfectly toasted to melt the Cheddar Cheese to give you one deliciously warm bite after another!

The Big Flat Greek Sandwich

It’s just a great name by itself!  The Big Flat Greek Sandwich is another of our Specialty Sandwiches on Ciabatta bread.

We layer Feta, Spinach, Cucumbers, Tomatoes, Red Onion, Banana Peppers, & Tzatziki Sauce on Ciabatta.  Add Gyro Meat as an extra ingredient if you wish.

Additional Authentic Italian and Specialty Subs

Delectable Dee’s

This is named after Tiffany’s grandmother, Delight Sieler.

We combine Provolone, Ham, and Salami, and top it off with lettuce, tomatoes, vinegar, oil & Italian Seasonings.

Here are some additional mouth-watering sandwiches available at Downtown Dempsey’s. We will add more photos soon, but in the meantime, please stop in and give these a try!

Charming Char’s – This wonderful sandwich is named after Loretta’s mother, Char Dempsey. It includes Provolone, Ham, and Mortadella, topped with lettuce, tomatoes, vinegar, oil & Italian Seasonings.

Joan’s Jubilee – We named this sandwich after Tiffany’s grandmother, Joan Condon. We like the combination of Provolone, Ham, and Capicola, topped with lettuce, tomatoes, vinegar, oil & Italian Seasonings.

Mighty Mike’s – Named after Loretta’s father, Mike Dempsey, this has a lot inside! We layer Provolone, Capicola, Mortadella, Prosciutto, and Salami and top it off with lettuce, tomatoes, vinegar, oil & Italian Seasonings.