Authentic Italian and Specialty Subs

Eating a sub or sandwich from Downtown Dempsey’s is a flavorful taste explosion for your mouth!

A lot of people ask us about our subs and sandwiches, and how they got their names. The sandwiches are named after people who are special to Tiffany.

We love to test flavor combinations, keeping in mind that people enjoy homemade traditional subs with quality ingredients that make your mouth want more! Each sandwich is hand-made, using only top-quality ingredients.

Below is a brief explanation and history of our sub sandwich creations.

We hope you are ready to bite into one of these delicious sandwiches! We have Specialty Subs and Authentic Italian Subs for you to choose from the next time you’re looking for a delicious lunch or dinner break!

Order ahead to pick up if you need lunch on the go, or sit back in our dining area and watch the downtown traffic while you relax and savor every bite!

An original Dempsey’s recipe with seven Italian meats, three cheese varieties then topped with lettuce, tomatoes, vinegar, oil and Italian seasonings! All toasted to perfection on a sub bun.


The sandwich that can be filled with gyro meat or left alone for vegetarian style! Ciabatta bread filled with feta, spinach, cucumbers, tomatoes, red onion, banana peppers then smothered in a fresh Tzatziki sauce.



We have about a dozen authentic Italian specialty subs and sandwiches to choose from!

Which one will be your favorite? You can check out our Facebook page for reviews and customer favorites HERE

Other family inspired original recipes include:

Charming Char’s – This wonderful sandwich is named after Char Dempsey. It includes Provolone, Ham, and Mortadella, topped with lettuce, tomatoes, vinegar, oil & Italian Seasonings.

Joan’s Jubilee – We named this sandwich after Tiffany’s grandmother, Joan Condon. We like the combination of Provolone, Ham, and Capicola, topped with lettuce, tomatoes, vinegar, oil & Italian Seasonings.

Mighty Mike’s – Named after Mike Dempsey, this has a lot inside! We layer Provolone, Capicola, Mortadella, Prosciutto, and Salami and top it off with lettuce, tomatoes, vinegar, oil & Italian Seasonings.

Tanner’s Toasted Tuna Pita Pocket- Named after and inspired by Tiffany’s husband, it’s a pita stuffed with tuna, mayo, onions, celery and cheddar cheese then toasted just right!

Grandpa Sam’s Sammie– Named after Tanner’s Grandpa, this is an improved B.L.T. on our 8″ sub bun. It includes a cheese blend, premium bacon toasted and topped with lettuce, tomato, cucumber and mayo.

Pennsylvania Pig– A sandwich inspired by Philly Cheesesteaks Cousin! A baked sandwich with sausage, white onion, double provolone, mushrooms, and green pepper.

The Incredible Miss Izzy– Inspired by a Dempsey’s family member, this sandwich is toasted with provolone and ham then topped with lettuce, tomatoes, vinegar, oil, and Italian Seasonings. 

Delectable Dee’s– an authentic Italian sub named after Tiffany’s Grandma. It’s made with provolone, ham, and salami and then topped with the lettuce, tomatoes, vinegar, oil and Italian Seasonings.